RSU vs Stock Options Tax
RSUs and stock options are the two ways tech companies pay in stock, and their taxes are near-opposites. RSUs are simple and certain: taxed at vesting, always. Options are a bet: worthless if the stock falls, and potentially much better taxed if it rises and you hold.
The short answer: RSUs are taxed as ordinary income at vesting on the full value, with 22% withheld, and later gains are capital gains. Options are not taxed at vesting or grant; NSOs tax the spread as ordinary income at exercise, and ISOs have no regular tax at exercise but can trigger AMT, with the whole gain potentially long-term capital gain. Options win when the stock rises a lot; RSUs win when it does not.
RSU vs options, side by side
| RSU | NSO | ISO | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Value if the stock falls | Still worth the shares | Worthless below the strike | Worthless below the strike |
| Taxed at vesting | Yes, full value as ordinary income | No | No |
| Taxed at exercise | — | Yes, spread as ordinary income | No regular tax; AMT item |
| Taxed at sale | Capital gain/loss from vesting value | Capital gain/loss from exercise value | Capital gain if qualifying; ordinary if not |
| Withholding | Yes, 22% at vesting | Yes, 22% at exercise | None at exercise |
| Best case tax | Ordinary on vest, capital after | Ordinary on spread, capital after | Entire gain long-term capital |
| Worst case tax | Ordinary on the full vest | Ordinary on the spread | AMT at exercise with no cash |
The choice is rarely yours: companies grant one or the other. What is yours is the timing. With RSUs, the main decision is whether to sell at vesting (usually the clean choice, since the tax is due either way) or hold and take stock risk on top of the tax already paid. With options, the decisions are when to exercise, whether to hold for a qualifying disposition, and how to manage the AMT.
Worked example
Two employees each receive stock worth $50,000 at the relevant date. The RSU holder is taxed on $50,000 at vesting as ordinary income. The ISO holder exercises at a $10 strike when the stock is $50, pays no regular tax, and sells later at $80 after a qualifying holding period: the $70,000 gain is long-term capital gain. If the stock instead falls to $30, the RSU holder still has $30,000 of shares (and already paid tax on $50,000), while the ISO holder's options are still worth exercising but the gain is far smaller.
What this calculator excludes
- This page is a guide. Use the calculators for your own numbers: RSU, ISO, NSO.
- State tax differs. This page is federal only. California, for example, taxes capital gains as ordinary income.
- Company policy matters. Trading windows, blackout periods, and holding requirements can limit when you can sell, whatever the tax answer is.
Related pages
- RSU tax calculator — tax on a vest.
- ISO vs NSO tax — the two option types, compared.
- How are stock options taxed? — all four types, compared.
- RSU capital gains tax — tax on selling after vesting.
Sources
- IRS Publication 525 — restricted stock, ISOs, NSOs.
- IRS Topic 427 — stock options.
- IRC 422 (ISOs), IRC 83 (NSOs and restricted stock).
Frequently asked questions
- Are RSUs or stock options taxed more?
- RSUs are taxed on the full value at vesting as ordinary income, which is certain and immediate. Options are taxed only on the spread, and ISOs can convert the whole gain to long-term capital gain, so options can be taxed less if the stock rises and you hold. If the stock falls, RSUs still have value and options may have none.
- Should I sell RSUs at vesting?
- Usually yes, from a tax point of view: the tax is due at vesting either way, so selling removes the stock risk without changing the tax. Holding means betting more of your wealth on one company.
- Do stock options get taxed at vesting?
- No. Options are not taxed at vesting. NSOs are taxed at exercise on the spread, and ISOs are taxed at sale (plus possible AMT at exercise). Only RSUs are taxed at vesting.
Figures last verified: November 17, 2026. Estimates only, not tax advice.